Stories / essay

Why Comic Sans Feels Out of Place: A Typography Tone Test

By Visual Design Journey2 min readComic Sans
Why Comic Sans Feels Out of Place: A Typography Tone Test

A speech balloon and a notice about a closed entrance can carry the same words. The reader approaches them with different expectations. Comic Sans can suggest an informal voice because its lettering draws from comics. Microsoft’s font notes include designer Vincent Connare’s account of that inspiration and identify the Windows 95 Plus! pack as an early release. That gives us a starting point for testing the face in context. Microsoft’s Comic Sans MS font notes

Watch the VDJ Short on Comic Sans.

Change the speaker while holding the words steady

Write “Please use the other door.” Put it in a speech balloon, on a handwritten-style note, and on a sign beside a gallery entrance. Set each in Comic Sans. Then set the same three layouts in a familiar sans serif, keeping the words, dimensions, and colour fixed. Check that both versions remain readable at the distance that matters for each setting.

Ask someone who seems to be speaking in each proof. Follow up by asking which door they think they should use. The first answer tells you something about the voice of the lettering. The second tells you whether the information survived the treatment. A more formal-looking font can still leave the practical direction unclear if the sign lacks an arrow.

Record the setting where the voice works

Keep the proof that best fits each situation. Describe the relationship between the lettering, speaker, and task. For an illustrated instruction sheet, a conversational voice may be welcome. For a shared building notice, the lettering needs to fit the way the rest of the building communicates. A type choice can make sense in one document and distract in another.

VDJ’s exercise on expressive typography gives you a second way to test what a typographic voice adds.

Discussion

Comments (0)

  1. No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Further reading
Watch the subject

Related YouTube film

The Story of Helvetica: The Font That Changed the World

Related YouTube film

What Is Contrast?

Reader-supported / Premium membership

Keep the journey going.

Become a Premium member and support independent design publishing.

  • Members-only stories
  • Full archive access
  • Ad-free reading

€5 / month

Or €50 / year · save two months

Become a Premium member

Cancel anytime. Access continues until your paid period ends.