Stories / essay

Serif vs Sans Serif: Compare the Reading Proof

By Visual Design Journey2 min readgraphic design
Serif vs Sans Serif: Compare the Reading Proof

A book caption can look sharp in one serif and crowded in another. The small strokes at the ends of letterforms tell you how to classify the first pair of fonts. They tell you much less about how a caption will read when it sits beneath a photograph at eleven points.

Keep the caption honest

Set two versions of the same credit line, including a photographer’s name, place and date. Use a serif in one version and a sans serif in the other. Keep the size, colour and available width the same. Look at the accented letters, the date and the punctuation before deciding which one is clearer. If one family wraps the credit into two lines, that is part of the comparison. The photograph needs a credit that fits its real space.

Now put the two families above a short article. Compare the printed pages or open each version at reading size on a phone. If one appears unexpectedly small, enlarge it until its lowercase letters look roughly comparable and check the wraps again. Two faces can share a nominal size while occupying quite different amounts of space.

Specify a job for each family

Write down what you need the face to do. A catalogue may need distinguishable figures and a reliable italic. An exhibition title may put more weight on the silhouette of the words. The useful observation is the one you can show in the proof.

On the web, the generic family at the end of the font stack gives the browser a fallback category. Test that fallback with the preferred font disabled. The W3C font family specification describes the role of generic families. For a longer specimen, see Choosing Type Across Screens.

Watch the Visual Design Journey video

Watch the VDJ Short on serif and sans serif

Discussion

Comments (0)

  1. No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Further reading
Watch the subject

Related YouTube film

The Story of Helvetica: The Font That Changed the World

Related YouTube film

Bauhaus: The School That Designed the Modern World

Reader-supported / Premium membership

Keep the journey going.

Become a Premium member and support independent design publishing.

  • Members-only stories
  • Full archive access
  • Ad-free reading

€5 / month

Or €50 / year · save two months

Become a Premium member

Cancel anytime. Access continues until your paid period ends.